Today, we begin a three-week daily practice on racism, privilege and power.
We will cover a lot of territory in the next 3+ weeks.
Some days require writing or meditation assignments other days involve the by-now familiar kinds of awareness practices that you do throughout your other daily activities.
Please put in the time and attention needed to gain real benefit.
What is racism?
Racism has been defined as “Any attitude, action or institutional structure which subordinates a person or group because of his or her color.”
U.S. Commission on Civil Rights
(apologies in advance to my fellow Canadian friends–you will undoubtedly notice a U.S. focus in some of this material.)
Given the wide-spread and persistent nature of racism, it may be surprising to discover that the concept of race is a fairly recent invention in human history. (Some scholars place its genesis in the early 18th century.) We use the term “invention” consciously, as race itself is a social
construct, and in that sense, not real.
“The concept of race is a social and cultural construction… Race simply cannot be tested or proven scientifically. It is clear that human populations are not unambiguous, clearly demarcated, biologically distinct groups. The concept of “race” has no validity… in the human species.”
American Anthropological Association
To a large degree, some of the more overt forms of racism are no longer socially acceptable. There has undoubtedly been progress on a number of social indicators. (Though we should keep in mind the memorable quote of Malcolm X):
“You don’t stick a knife in a man’s back 9 inches and then pull it out 6 inches and say you’re making progress.”
However we hold the question of progress, as the most overt forms of bigotry and discrimination becomes less obvious, it unfortunately becomes easier (for those not directly impacted) to not see or deny racism’s existence.
Why Take This On?
People of color generally know from their own experience all too well the need to heal the wounds of racism. Taking on racism is tough work. White people, who have the enormous privilege of not having to face it regularly, need to come to a personal understanding of why do this work.
There is, of course, a strong moral imperative to addressing injustice. Most of you reading this practice are committed to values such as compassion, respect, and justice. Once our eyes are opened to the pervasiveness of racism, most of us will naturally feel a desire to respond.
However, it’s also important for us to understand that our existing missions as leaders almost invariably inter-relate with issues of racism. Racism is a lens on reality that applies to most social and institutional interactions and dynamics. Former American Sociological Association president Joe R. Feagin says that the United States can be characterized as a “total
racist society” because racism is used to organize every social institution.
Many of society’s ills cannot be successfully addressed, without healing racism. Our success in addressing issues of environment, democracy, human rights, the economy, crime, health, etc. will depend on our ability to address racial injustice, and build meaningful relationships, alliances
and power across racial and ethnic boundaries.
You are each leaders of people and organizations in a society that has become truly multi-cultural, with whites becoming a minority in many of your lifetimes. We must learn to create bonds of understanding, compassion and shared interests across the barriers that divide us, and unleash the creative power of our diversity.
The first step in our practice is to fine-tune our “radar.” There is evidence of racism all around us, but it may have become normalized, or we’re not sensitive to the signs.
“Racism is so universal in this country, so widespread and deep-seated, that it is invisible because it is so normal.”
Shirley Chisholm
Observing Racism
It is important to understand that contemporary racism is often not malicious by intent. But we assert that certain behaviors are racist regardless of intent.
Valerie Batts in her article “Is Reconciliation Possible?” outlines four levels of
racism:
1. Personal
At this level, racism is prejudice or bias. It is the maintenance of conscious or unconscious attitudes and feelings that whites are superior and that blacks or other people of color are inferior or that these groups’ differences are not acceptable in some way. Personal level racism
includes cognitive or affective misinformation or both. The misinformation may be learned directly, as through overt messages, or indirectly as through observation.
2. Interpersonal
Behaviors based on conscious or unconscious biased assumptions About self and other are interpersonal manifestations of racism. It is often through uncomfortable or tense cross-cultural interactions that individuals discover subtle racist behaviors within themselves or others.
3. Institutional
An examination of power relationships reveals institutional racism. The question to be asked is, to what extent do the intended and unintended consequences of policies, practices, laws, styles, rules, and procedures function to the advantage of the dominant group and to the disadvantage of people of color? To the extent that whites in this society have the
political, economic, educational, social, and historical power and access to institutionalize prejudices (i.e., the myths of white superiority and black inferiority) against blacks and other people of color, whites are in a position to practice or maintain institutional racism.
4. Cultural
The ability to define European-American and Western cultural preferences as “right and beautiful” is the consequence of having institutional power and access in this country. When the standards of appropriate action, thought, and expression of a particular group are
perceived either overtly or subtlety as negative or less than, cultural racism has occurred. Conformity to the dominant culture is then viewed as “normal” when in fact the myth of the inherent superiority of the group setting the standards is operating. If such is the case, it is likely that a given individual will need to change her behavior to fit those of the dominant group just to be accepted as competent, attractive, or talented.
We will be using this framework of four levels to carefully watch and listen to life around us, attuning all our senses and mind to discerning racism in all its forms.
For today’s practice, write down 5 examples of each of the four levels of racism. As much as possible, try to choose examples that you in some way see or encounter in yourself, in those around you, in the media, and in your work.
Personal
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
Interpersonal
1.
2.
3.
4.
5
Institutional
1.
2.
3.
4.
5
Cultural
1.
2.
3.
4.
5
Many, many thanks to Akaya Winwood for the development of of Practices #12-18 people of color in Part III.
Adapted from the practices of Robert Gass and Akaya Winwood.